See that was me...in the books, I'm totally Edward, but in the movies, I just don't really like Patterson all that much. (And what is with those eyebrows???) shrug. I TOTALLY like Jacob better. BUT, going by the storyline in the BOOKS, I have to say, she never could have chosen any but Edward. She never had a choice, not really. Jacob would have always been second-place in her heart. So, how can you argue that, you know?
I'd love to know what you think: